Wired Says ‘Please Let The Internet Die.’ Some Of Us Are Busy Building A Better One.
“It remains incredible — and disturbing — to me how many people now think of the entire internet as being made up of a few giant enshittifying companies. I understand why that is. The big companies absolutely do dominate much of the internet, and it’s [close to impossible](
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/31/technology/blocking-the-tech-giants.html) to avoid them entirely. But that doesn’t mean that that’s the entirety of the internet. And when you act as if it is, you do real damage to the good parts of the internet that still exist outside of the blast radius of those giants.”
So true that there is far more to the Internet than Google, Facebook, TikTok, etc. Long before these commercial sites/networks existed, there was a quality Internet full of useful discussion and information. That still exists today, but not on Google, Facebook, etc.
The reason we see such slop today, is because many of the big networks are commercially driven. A massive centralise service requires massively expensive hosting facilities. Anyone can pay to advertise and have their posts pushed in front of you. Creators are rewarded financially for views, and they max out those views, which means they are not too concerned about quality, fact checking, etc. We've seen with Facebook already, that the more controversial and antagonising a post is, the more views it will get.
It is a circle that the commercial big tech companies feed. If there was no money paid for posts, and there was no advertising, there would be nothing to drive the slop, or motivate driving it.
As the linked article shows, it has a reference to the “test suite” and you can see there are many sites and networks out there that are not driven by the commercial side of things. I get that the Internet is a lot bigger now, but that is also why decentralisation has taken off, so that loads are spread across different hosting instances. It was also why the founder of the decentralised Mastodon network was trying to encourage new users to sign up at smaller servers and not all flock to the main server. It is also why on networks like Nostr, the user owns their profile, and that profile is not linked to anyone hosting anything. In fact, Nostr has no servers as we know them where you log in to read a feed.
It reminds me of traditional wet shaving, where today's youth have been indoctrinated and PR'd by Gillette into forgetting there was once a cheaper better way of shaving (it still exists today, but one has to go looking for it).
We have alternatives, and we do still have an Internet worth worrying about. The question is, are you going to take the blue pill or the red pill?
See
Wired Says ‘Please Let The Internet Die.’ Some Of Us Are Busy Building A Better One.It remains incredible — and disturbing — to me how many people now think of the entire internet as being made up of a few giant enshittifying companies. I understand why that is. The big companies …
#technology #bigtech #enshittification